Is It Real? Muscle Car Clone Checklists
Is It Real? Muscle Car Clone Checklists
Badges, stripes and hoods are easy to add, so a lot of the SS, Z28, Judge, W-30 and Hemi cars for sale today started life as something else. These checklists show what to look at on the car and which papers prove it. Clones aren't bad cars, but they should be priced and sold as clones.
Start here: checks for every car
- Match the VIN on the title to the VIN plate on the dash. Look at the rivets: original plates use specific rivets, and wrong or replaced rivets are a red flag.
- Check the cowl tag or fender tag for signs it was moved, re-riveted or stamped by hand.
- Check the engine and transmission stamps (partial VIN and suffix code) against the car. A matching engine helps, but a correct engine can be moved into another car.
- Ask for the paperwork: build sheet, window sticker, dealer invoice, Protect-O-Plate (GM) or broadcast sheet (Mopar). Factory paper is the strongest proof.
- Use the factory records services where they exist, such as Pontiac Historic Services for Pontiacs.
Decode the numbers with our tools: A-body VIN & cowl tag · Camaro & Firebird · GM engine codes · GM casting numbers · Pontiac VIN · Mopar VIN & fender tag
Chevelle SS (1964–72)
| Years | What proves it |
|---|---|
| 1966–68 SS396 | The SS396 was its own series, so the VIN starts with 138 (body 17 or 67 for 1966–67; 37, 67 or 80 in 1968). A Malibu VIN (136) is not an SS396. Careful: 1967–68 Concours wagons and the Monte Carlo also used 138 VINs, so check the body code too. |
| 1968 El Camino SS396 | 1968 is the only year the El Camino SS can be confirmed by the VIN. |
| 1969–70 | The SS became an option (Z25 SS396; 1970 also Z15 SS454), so the VIN does not show it. Cars built in Oshawa, Ontario show the SS option code on the cowl tag. For 1969, a cowl tag paint code of 72 (Hugger Orange) means a true SS-optioned car. Otherwise you need the engine code, build sheet and other documents together. |
| 1971–72 | The Z15 SS package was mostly an appearance option and could come with small blocks, so documents are the only real proof. |
Camaro Z28 (1967–69)
- VIN: it doesn't show the Z28 on 1967–69 cars. It only shows six or V8, body and year.
- 1967 cowl tag: look for the Fisher option code 4L.
- 1968 cowl tag: has nothing that identifies a Z28. Rely on the engine and paperwork.
- 1969 cowl tag: Norwood cars built from about December 1968 carry an X code. Z28s are X33 or X77; an X11 tag is not a Z28.
- Engine: the 302 suffix is MO or MP in 1967–68 and DZ in 1969, with a partial VIN that matches the car.
- Paperwork: Protect-O-Plate, build sheet or dealer invoice. No single number tells the whole story, so compare them all.
Decode a Camaro cowl tag · Camaro axle codes · Camaro trim codes
Pontiac GTO & The Judge
- 1966–71: the GTO was its own series, so the VIN starts with 242. A VIN starting 233, 235 or 237 is a Tempest or LeMans.
- 1964–65: the GTO was an option on the LeMans. Some plants (Pontiac and Kansas City) marked it with a 5N code on the cowl tag; others didn't.
- The Judge: it was a factory option on a 242 GTO, never a dealer add-on. Apart from the stripes, badges and spoiler, every Judge part could be ordered on a regular GTO, so only the paperwork proves a Judge. A 1969 car with paint code 72 (Carousel Red) is a good sign but not proof.
- 1969 Ram Air III Judge engine codes: WS (4-speed) or YZ (automatic) stamped on the front of the block, with the partial VIN.
- Get the PHS documents. Pontiac Historic Services supplies a copy of the original factory invoice or billing card for the VIN. Serious buyers expect them.
Decode a Pontiac VIN · Pontiac engine codes · Pontiac paint codes
Oldsmobile 4-4-2 & W-30
- 1968–71: the 4-4-2 had its own series code, so the VIN starts with 344 (for example 34487 for a hardtop). Before 1968 and from 1972 on, the 4-4-2 was an option package, so you need documents.
- Cowl tag: 1968–69 4-4-2s often carry Cutlass S body codes on the cowl tag even though the VIN says 4-4-2. That is correct for those years, so go by the VIN.
- A 344 VIN proves a 4-4-2, not a W-30. A 1968–71 4-4-2 can be converted to W-30 parts, so check the parts and the paperwork. The build sheet is the most reliable proof.
- Lansing: W-30 cars from 1966–72 were built in Lansing, so the VIN's 7th character should be M.
Reading an Olds engine
| Where | What you'll find |
|---|---|
| Block pad, driver side, below the head (1968 on) | The partial VIN of the car the engine came in. On a W-30 it should match the last 8 characters of the VIN. |
| Oil filler tube (1968 on) | A stamped engine unit number whose first digit is the last digit of the model year (0 = 1970), plus a paper decal with a two-letter engine code. The decal is usually long gone and is reproduced, so treat it as a clue only. |
| Cylinder head (1964–67) | A prefix letter, sequence number and suffix letter on the original driver-side head. G = high compression, L = low compression. |
| Block ID letter | 1965 400 = B (casting 389298) · 1966–67 400 = E (390925) · 1968–69 400 = G (396026) · 1970–72 455 = F (396021) · 1973–76 455 = Fa |
W-30 checklist by year
| Year | What to look for |
|---|---|
| 1966 | Tri-carb, manual transmission only, no convertibles, battery in the trunk. "B" heads with "-1" after the casting number. Built in June 1966. 54 factory cars. |
| 1967 | Single four-barrel, red inner fender liners (first year), first year for an automatic (TH-400). 502 factory cars. |
| 1968 | VIN 344_78M. "D" heads. Red plastic inner fenders with holes behind the headlights. Automatic is a TH-400 coded OW. Bumblebee stripes were mandatory. |
| 1969 | "D" heads. Red inner fenders. Rear axle codes TM (3.42), TO (3.91) or TY (4.33). Automatic coded OW. |
| 1970 | VIN 344__M. "F" heads. Aluminum intake 406115 cast "OLDSMOBILE W-455" or "OLDS W-455". Distributor 1111979. Red inner fenders. Automatic coded OW. Rear codes TM (3.42) or TO (3.91); SF (3.23) on A/C automatics. First year A/C and power brakes were offered. |
| 1971 | "H" heads. Aluminum intake 407570 cast "OLDS W-455". Red inner fenders. Automatic coded OW, manual M-22. 920 built, 110 of them convertibles. |
| 1972 | X as the engine character in the VIN marks a W-30. Black inner fenders (only the first 10 cars had red). The glovebox usually reads Cutlass or Cutlass Supreme. |
Decode a 4-4-2 VIN & cowl tag · Olds casting numbers · Cutlass & 4-4-2 parts
Hemi ’Cuda, Road Runner, Charger & other Mopars
- Engine letter in the VIN: the 5th character is the engine. On 1970–71 cars, R = 426 Hemi, so a 1970 Hemi ’Cuda reads BS23R0B…. Other key letters: U = 440, V = 440 Six Pack, N = 383 HP.
- Fender tag: the engine code should agree with the VIN, for example E74 for the Hemi, plus the transmission code (D21 = 4-speed, D32 = heavy-duty automatic).
- Hidden numbers: Mopars carry partial VINs on the radiator support, cowl, engine and transmission, and a VIN sticker on the door. Matching all of them is strong evidence.
- Broadcast sheet: the factory build sheet, often found under the seat springs, carpet or headliner.
- Professional inspection: for high-dollar Mopars, a recognized fender tag and body authentication expert is worth the fee.
Decode a Mopar VIN & fender tag · Mopar paint codes · Mopar production numbers
Building it right?
ChevelleCamaroGTOCutlass & 4-4-2’CudaEmblemsDecals & Stripes
Frequently asked questions
How can I tell if a Chevelle is a real SS?
How do I know if a 1969 Camaro is a real Z28?
Is every GTO VIN 242?
How do I tell if an Olds 4-4-2 is a real W-30?
How can I check a Hemi ’Cuda VIN?
Compiled from Chevelle, Camaro, Pontiac, Oldsmobile and Mopar registries and research groups, cross-checked. This is a guide, not an appraisal. Not affiliated with General Motors or Stellantis.